Re: indentured servants my ass.....
From what I learned about it, the first option is correct. Logically speaking, that's correct IF he commanded us to lie cheat, steal, torture, etc, then lying, cheating, stealing, torturing, etc would be morally right. BUT, God did not command us to not lie, cheat, steal, torture, etc, so that is not the case.
As to benevolence being rendered empty, that is also correct: God's benevolence does not come from commanding us to what is right, or true, God is not benevolent for commanding us to do what God commands us to do.
God's benevolence comes from his character, which is not arbitrary. God's benevolence can be seen in the consequences for not doing what he commands. God provides a way for saving those that wish to be saved, and honoring the choice of those that don't. As R.C Sproul put it "We are saved from God, by God" and some will receive justice, some will receive mercy, but nobody will receive injustice.
BTW, hell is not some eternal torture by fire either, it is eternal separation from God. God's benevolence is also seen by honoring everyone's choices, those that don't wish to follow his commands will not be forced to in the afterlife either. There may be some disappointment from making that choice, some weeping, but the idea of some red dude, fire and a pitchfork from the Tom and Jerry cartoons isn't accurate.
Is what is right that way because God commands it, or does God command it because it is already morally right?
As to benevolence being rendered empty, that is also correct: God's benevolence does not come from commanding us to what is right, or true, God is not benevolent for commanding us to do what God commands us to do.
God's benevolence comes from his character, which is not arbitrary. God's benevolence can be seen in the consequences for not doing what he commands. God provides a way for saving those that wish to be saved, and honoring the choice of those that don't. As R.C Sproul put it "We are saved from God, by God" and some will receive justice, some will receive mercy, but nobody will receive injustice.
BTW, hell is not some eternal torture by fire either, it is eternal separation from God. God's benevolence is also seen by honoring everyone's choices, those that don't wish to follow his commands will not be forced to in the afterlife either. There may be some disappointment from making that choice, some weeping, but the idea of some red dude, fire and a pitchfork from the Tom and Jerry cartoons isn't accurate.
Comment